fix(xep,core): Ensure in-order processing of incoming stanzas

packages/moxxmpp/lib/src/connection.dart

@@ -25,12 +25,12 @@ import 'package:moxxmpp/src/settings.dart';
 import 'package:moxxmpp/src/socket.dart';
 import 'package:moxxmpp/src/stanza.dart';
 import 'package:moxxmpp/src/stringxml.dart';
+import 'package:moxxmpp/src/util/incoming_queue.dart';
 import 'package:moxxmpp/src/util/queue.dart';
 import 'package:moxxmpp/src/util/typed_map.dart';
 import 'package:moxxmpp/src/xeps/xep_0030/xep_0030.dart';
 import 'package:moxxmpp/src/xeps/xep_0198/xep_0198.dart';
 import 'package:moxxmpp/src/xeps/xep_0352.dart';
-import 'package:synchronized/synchronized.dart';
 import 'package:uuid/uuid.dart';
 
 /// The states the XmppConnection can be in
@@ -90,9 +90,12 @@ class XmppConnection {
       },
     );
 
+    _incomingStanzaQueue = IncomingStanzaQueue(handleXmlStream);
     _socketStream = _socket.getDataStream();
     // TODO(Unknown): Handle on done
-    _socketStream.transform(_streamParser).forEach(handleXmlStream);
+    _socketStream
+        .transform(_streamParser)
+        .forEach(_incomingStanzaQueue.addStanza);
     _socket.getEventStream().listen(handleSocketEvent);
 
     _stanzaQueue = AsyncStanzaQueue(
@@ -170,10 +173,6 @@ class XmppConnection {
   T? getNegotiatorById<T extends XmppFeatureNegotiatorBase>(String id) =>
       _negotiationsHandler.getNegotiatorById<T>(id);
 
-  /// Prevent data from being passed to _currentNegotiator.negotiator while the negotiator
-  /// is still running.
-  final Lock _negotiationLock = Lock();
-
   /// The logger for the class
   final Logger _log = Logger('XmppConnection');
 
@@ -182,6 +181,8 @@ class XmppConnection {
 
   bool get isAuthenticated => _isAuthenticated;
 
+  late final IncomingStanzaQueue _incomingStanzaQueue;
+
   late final AsyncStanzaQueue _stanzaQueue;
 
   /// Returns the JID we authenticate with and add the resource that we have bound.
@@ -591,6 +592,8 @@ class XmppConnection {
       await _reconnectionPolicy.setShouldReconnect(true);
     }
 
+    _incomingStanzaQueue.negotiationsDone = true;
+
     // Tell consumers of the event stream that we're done with stream feature
     // negotiations
     await _sendEvent(
@@ -828,17 +831,17 @@ class XmppConnection {
         // causing (a) the negotiator to become confused and (b) the stanzas/nonzas to be
         // missed. This causes the data to wait while the negotiator is running and thus
         // prevent this issue.
-        await _negotiationLock.synchronized(() async {
+        if (_routingState != RoutingState.negotiating) {
-          if (_routingState != RoutingState.negotiating) {
+          unawaited(handleXmlStream(event));
-            unawaited(handleXmlStream(event));
+          return;
-            return;
+        }
-          }
 
-          await _negotiationsHandler.negotiate(event);
+        await _negotiationsHandler.negotiate(event);
-        });
         break;
       case RoutingState.handleStanzas:
+        _log.finest('Handling ${node.tag} (${node.attributes["id"]})');
         await _handleStanza(node);
+        _log.finest('Handling ${node.tag} (${node.attributes["id"]}) done');
         break;
       case RoutingState.preConnection:
       case RoutingState.error:
@@ -903,6 +906,7 @@ class XmppConnection {
     // Kill a possibly existing connection
     _socket.close();
 
+    _incomingStanzaQueue.negotiationsDone = false;
     await _reconnectionPolicy.reset();
     _enableReconnectOnSuccess = enableReconnectOnSuccess;
     if (shouldReconnect) {

packages/moxxmpp/lib/src/parser.dart

@@ -57,9 +57,10 @@ class _ChunkedConversionBuffer<S, T> {
 }
 
 /// A buffer to put between a socket's input and a full XML stream.
-class XMPPStreamParser extends StreamTransformerBase<String, XMPPStreamObject> {
+class XMPPStreamParser
-  final StreamController<XMPPStreamObject> _streamController =
+    extends StreamTransformerBase<String, List<XMPPStreamObject>> {
-      StreamController<XMPPStreamObject>();
+  final StreamController<List<XMPPStreamObject>> _streamController =
+      StreamController<List<XMPPStreamObject>>();
 
   /// Turns a String into a list of [XmlEvent]s in a chunked fashion.
   _ChunkedConversionBuffer<String, XmlEvent> _eventBuffer =
@@ -117,13 +118,14 @@ class XMPPStreamParser extends StreamTransformerBase<String, XMPPStreamObject> {
   }
 
   @override
-  Stream<XMPPStreamObject> bind(Stream<String> stream) {
+  Stream<List<XMPPStreamObject>> bind(Stream<String> stream) {
     // We do not want to use xml's toXmlEvents and toSubtreeEvents methods as they
     // create streams we cannot close. We need to be able to destroy and recreate an
     // XML parser whenever we start a new connection.
     stream.listen((input) {
       final events = _eventBuffer.convert(input);
       final streamHeaderEvents = _streamHeaderSelector.convert(events);
+      final objects = List<XMPPStreamObject>.empty(growable: true);
 
       // Process the stream header separately.
       for (final event in streamHeaderEvents) {
@@ -135,7 +137,7 @@ class XMPPStreamParser extends StreamTransformerBase<String, XMPPStreamObject> {
           continue;
         }
 
-        _streamController.add(
+        objects.add(
           XMPPStreamHeader(
             Map<String, String>.fromEntries(
               event.attributes.map((attr) {
@@ -151,13 +153,15 @@ class XMPPStreamParser extends StreamTransformerBase<String, XMPPStreamObject> {
       final children = _childBuffer.convert(childEvents);
       for (final node in children) {
         if (node.nodeType == XmlNodeType.ELEMENT) {
-          _streamController.add(
+          objects.add(
             XMPPStreamElement(
               XMLNode.fromXmlElement(node as XmlElement),
             ),
           );
         }
       }
+
+      _streamController.add(objects);
     });
 
     return _streamController.stream;

packages/moxxmpp/lib/src/util/incoming_queue.dart

@@ -0,0 +1,99 @@
+import 'dart:async';
+import 'dart:collection';
+import 'package:logging/logging.dart';
+import 'package:moxxmpp/src/parser.dart';
+import 'package:synchronized/synchronized.dart';
+
+typedef LockResult = (Completer<void>?, XMPPStreamObject);
+
+class IncomingStanzaQueue {
+  IncomingStanzaQueue(this._callback);
+
+  final Queue<Completer<void>> _queue = Queue();
+
+  final Future<void> Function(XMPPStreamObject) _callback;
+  bool _isRunning = false;
+
+  final Lock _lock = Lock();
+
+  final Logger _log = Logger('IncomingStanzaQueue');
+
+  bool negotiationsDone = false;
+
+  Future<void> _processStreamObject(
+    Future<void>? future,
+    XMPPStreamObject object,
+  ) async {
+    if (future == null) {
+      if (object is XMPPStreamElement) {
+        _log.finest(
+          'Bypassing queue for ${object.node.tag} (${object.node.attributes["id"]})',
+        );
+      }
+      return _callback(object);
+    }
+
+    // Wait for our turn.
+    await future;
+
+    // Run the callback.
+    if (object is XMPPStreamElement) {
+      _log.finest('Running callback for ${object.node.toXml()}');
+    }
+    await _callback(object);
+    if (object is XMPPStreamElement) {
+      _log.finest(
+        'Callback for ${object.node.tag} (${object.node.attributes["id"]}) done',
+      );
+    }
+
+    // Run the next entry.
+    _log.finest('Entering second lock...');
+    await _lock.synchronized(() {
+      _log.finest('Second lock entered...');
+      if (_queue.isNotEmpty) {
+        _log.finest('New queue size: ${_queue.length - 1}');
+        _queue.removeFirst().complete();
+      } else {
+        _isRunning = false;
+        _log.finest('New queue size: 0');
+      }
+    });
+  }
+
+  Future<void> addStanza(List<XMPPStreamObject> objects) async {
+    _log.finest('Entering initial lock...');
+    await _lock.synchronized(() {
+      _log.finest('Lock entered...');
+
+      for (final object in objects) {
+        if (canBypassQueue(object)) {
+          unawaited(
+            _processStreamObject(null, object),
+          );
+          continue;
+        }
+
+        final completer = Completer<void>();
+        if (_isRunning) {
+          _queue.add(completer);
+        } else {
+          _isRunning = true;
+          completer.complete();
+        }
+
+        unawaited(
+          _processStreamObject(completer.future, object),
+        );
+      }
+    });
+  }
+
+  bool canBypassQueue(XMPPStreamObject object) {
+    // TODO: Ask the StanzaAwaiter if the stanza is awaited
+    return object is XMPPStreamElement &&
+        negotiationsDone &&
+        object.node.tag == 'iq' &&
+        ['result', 'error'].contains(object.node.attributes['type'] as String?);
+  }
+}

packages/moxxmpp/lib/src/xeps/xep_0045/xep_0045.dart

@@ -251,19 +251,23 @@ class MUCManager extends XmppManagerBase {
     StanzaHandlerData state,
   ) async {
     if (presence.from == null) {
+      logger.finest('Ignoring presence as it has no from attribute');
       return state;
     }
 
     final from = JID.fromString(presence.from!);
     final bareFrom = from.toBare();
     return _cacheLock.synchronized(() {
+      logger.finest('Lock aquired for presence from ${presence.from}');
       final room = _mucRoomCache[bareFrom];
       if (room == null) {
+        logger.finest('Ignoring presence as it does not belong to a room');
         return state;
       }
 
       if (from.resource.isEmpty) {
         // TODO(Unknown): Handle presence from the room itself.
+        logger.finest('Ignoring presence as it has no resource');
         return state;
       }
 
@@ -311,6 +315,7 @@ class MUCManager extends XmppManagerBase {
 
         // Set the nick to make sure we're in sync with the MUC.
         room.nick = from.resource;
+        logger.finest('Self-presence handled');
         return StanzaHandlerData(
           true,
           false,
@@ -360,8 +365,10 @@ class MUCManager extends XmppManagerBase {
         }
 
         room.members[from.resource] = member;
+        logger.finest('${from.resource} added to the member list');
       }
 
+      logger.finest('Ran through');
       return StanzaHandlerData(
         true,
         false,
@@ -398,7 +405,8 @@ class MUCManager extends XmppManagerBase {
   ) async {
     final fromJid = JID.fromString(message.from!);
     final roomJid = fromJid.toBare();
-    return _mucRoomCache.synchronized(() {
+    return _cacheLock.synchronized(() {
+      logger.finest('Lock aquired for message from ${message.from}');
       final roomState = _mucRoomCache[roomJid];
       if (roomState == null) {
         return state;

packages/moxxmpp/lib/src/xeps/xep_0115.dart

@@ -173,39 +173,15 @@ class EntityCapabilitiesManager extends XmppManagerBase {
     });
   }
 
-  @visibleForTesting
+  Future<void> _performQuery(Stanza presence, String ver,
-  Future<StanzaHandlerData> onPresence(
+      String hashFunctionName, String capabilityNode, JID from) async {
-    Stanza stanza,
-    StanzaHandlerData state,
-  ) async {
-    if (stanza.from == null) {
-      return state;
-    }
-
-    final from = JID.fromString(stanza.from!);
-    final c = stanza.firstTag('c', xmlns: capsXmlns)!;
-
-    final hashFunctionName = c.attributes['hash'] as String?;
-    final capabilityNode = c.attributes['node'] as String?;
-    final ver = c.attributes['ver'] as String?;
-    if (hashFunctionName == null || capabilityNode == null || ver == null) {
-      return state;
-    }
-
-    // Check if we know of the hash
-    final isCached =
-        await _cacheLock.synchronized(() => _capHashCache.containsKey(ver));
-    if (isCached) {
-      return state;
-    }
-
     final dm = getAttributes().getManagerById<DiscoManager>(discoManager)!;
     final discoRequest = await dm.discoInfoQuery(
       from,
       node: capabilityNode,
     );
     if (discoRequest.isType<StanzaError>()) {
-      return state;
+      return;
     }
     final discoInfo = discoRequest.get<DiscoInfo>();
 
@@ -220,7 +196,7 @@ class EntityCapabilitiesManager extends XmppManagerBase {
           discoInfo,
         ),
       );
-      return state;
+      return;
     }
 
     // Validate the disco#info result according to XEP-0115 § 5.4
@@ -234,7 +210,7 @@ class EntityCapabilitiesManager extends XmppManagerBase {
         logger.warning(
           'Malformed disco#info response: More than one equal identity',
         );
-        return state;
+        return;
       }
     }
 
@@ -245,7 +221,7 @@ class EntityCapabilitiesManager extends XmppManagerBase {
         logger.warning(
           'Malformed disco#info response: More than one equal feature',
         );
-        return state;
+        return;
       }
     }
 
@@ -273,7 +249,7 @@ class EntityCapabilitiesManager extends XmppManagerBase {
           logger.warning(
             'Malformed disco#info response: Extended Info FORM_TYPE contains more than one value(s) of different value.',
           );
-          return state;
+          return;
         }
       }
 
@@ -288,7 +264,7 @@ class EntityCapabilitiesManager extends XmppManagerBase {
         logger.warning(
           'Malformed disco#info response: More than one Extended Disco Info forms with the same FORM_TYPE value',
         );
-        return state;
+        return;
       }
 
       // Check if the field type is hidden
@@ -325,7 +301,43 @@ class EntityCapabilitiesManager extends XmppManagerBase {
         'Capability hash mismatch from $from: Received "$ver", expected "$computedCapabilityHash".',
       );
     }
+  }
 
+  @visibleForTesting
+  Future<StanzaHandlerData> onPresence(
+    Stanza stanza,
+    StanzaHandlerData state,
+  ) async {
+    if (stanza.from == null) {
+      return state;
+    }
+
+    final from = JID.fromString(stanza.from!);
+    final c = stanza.firstTag('c', xmlns: capsXmlns)!;
+
+    final hashFunctionName = c.attributes['hash'] as String?;
+    final capabilityNode = c.attributes['node'] as String?;
+    final ver = c.attributes['ver'] as String?;
+    if (hashFunctionName == null || capabilityNode == null || ver == null) {
+      return state;
+    }
+
+    // Check if we know of the hash
+    final isCached =
+        await _cacheLock.synchronized(() => _capHashCache.containsKey(ver));
+    if (isCached) {
+      return state;
+    }
+
+    unawaited(
+      _performQuery(
+        stanza,
+        ver,
+        hashFunctionName,
+        capabilityNode,
+        from,
+      ),
+    );
     return state;
   }
 

packages/moxxmpp/packages/moxxmpp/lib/src/util/incoming_queue.dart

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+

packages/moxxmpp/pubspec.yaml

@@ -8,6 +8,7 @@ environment:
   sdk: '>=3.0.0 <4.0.0'
 
 dependencies:
+  async_queue: ^1.3.0
   collection: ^1.16.0
   cryptography: ^2.0.5
   hex: ^0.2.0

packages/moxxmpp/test/xmpp_parser_test.dart

@@ -11,14 +11,16 @@ void main() {
     final controller = StreamController<String>();
 
     unawaited(
-      controller.stream.transform(parser).forEach((event) {
+      controller.stream.transform(parser).forEach((events) {
-        if (event is! XMPPStreamElement) return;
+        for (final event in events) {
-        final node = event.node;
+          if (event is! XMPPStreamElement) continue;
+          final node = event.node;
 
-        if (node.tag == 'childa') {
+          if (node.tag == 'childa') {
-          childa = true;
+            childa = true;
-        } else if (node.tag == 'childb') {
+          } else if (node.tag == 'childb') {
-          childb = true;
+            childb = true;
+          }
         }
       }),
     );
@@ -36,14 +38,16 @@ void main() {
     final controller = StreamController<String>();
 
     unawaited(
-      controller.stream.transform(parser).forEach((event) {
+      controller.stream.transform(parser).forEach((events) {
-        if (event is! XMPPStreamElement) return;
+        for (final event in events) {
-        final node = event.node;
+          if (event is! XMPPStreamElement) continue;
+          final node = event.node;
 
-        if (node.tag == 'childa') {
+          if (node.tag == 'childa') {
-          childa = true;
+            childa = true;
-        } else if (node.tag == 'childb') {
+          } else if (node.tag == 'childb') {
-          childb = true;
+            childb = true;
+          }
         }
       }),
     );
@@ -64,14 +68,16 @@ void main() {
     final controller = StreamController<String>();
 
     unawaited(
-      controller.stream.transform(parser).forEach((event) {
+      controller.stream.transform(parser).forEach((events) {
-        if (event is! XMPPStreamElement) return;
+        for (final event in events) {
-        final node = event.node;
+          if (event is! XMPPStreamElement) continue;
+          final node = event.node;
 
-        if (node.tag == 'childa') {
+          if (node.tag == 'childa') {
-          childa = true;
+            childa = true;
-        } else if (node.tag == 'childb') {
+          } else if (node.tag == 'childb') {
-          childb = true;
+            childb = true;
+          }
         }
       }),
     );
@@ -93,13 +99,15 @@ void main() {
     final controller = StreamController<String>();
 
     unawaited(
-      controller.stream.transform(parser).forEach((node) {
+      controller.stream.transform(parser).forEach((events) {
-        if (node is XMPPStreamElement) {
+        for (final event in events) {
-          if (node.node.tag == 'childa') {
+          if (event is XMPPStreamElement) {
-            childa = true;
+            if (event.node.tag == 'childa') {
+              childa = true;
+            }
+          } else if (event is XMPPStreamHeader) {
+            attrs = event.attributes;
           }
-        } else if (node is XMPPStreamHeader) {
-          attrs = node.attributes;
         }
       }),
     );
@@ -118,11 +126,13 @@ void main() {
     var gotFeatures = false;
     unawaited(
       controller.stream.transform(parser).forEach(
-        (event) {
+        (events) {
-          if (event is! XMPPStreamElement) return;
+          for (final event in events) {
+            if (event is! XMPPStreamElement) continue;
 
-          if (event.node.tag == 'stream:features') {
+            if (event.node.tag == 'stream:features') {
-            gotFeatures = true;
+              gotFeatures = true;
+            }
           }
         },
       ),
@@ -157,4 +167,27 @@ void main() {
     await Future<void>.delayed(const Duration(seconds: 1));
     expect(gotFeatures, true);
   });
+
+  test('Test the order of concatenated stanzas', () async {
+    // NOTE: This seems weird, but it turns out that not keeping this order leads to
+    //       MUC joins (on Moxxy) not catching every bit of presence before marking the
+    //       MUC as joined.
+    final parser = XMPPStreamParser();
+    final controller = StreamController<String>();
+    var called = false;
+
+    unawaited(
+      controller.stream.transform(parser).forEach((events) {
+        expect(events.isNotEmpty, true);
+        expect((events[0] as XMPPStreamElement).node.tag, 'childa');
+        expect((events[1] as XMPPStreamElement).node.tag, 'childb');
+        expect((events[2] as XMPPStreamElement).node.tag, 'childc');
+        called = true;
+      }),
+    );
+    controller.add('<childa /><childb /><childc />');
+
+    await Future<void>.delayed(const Duration(seconds: 2));
+    expect(called, true);
+  });
 }